Why Did My House Rate Lower In My Second EPC Assessment?

”Yesterday, I had a surveyor come to my house to assess it for the Energy Performance Certificate (EPC). This is a house that I am letting out. My mortgage was due to be renewed so my mortgage advisor asked me to get an EPC done asap.

My last EPC was done in 2014 when it rated as E43. To get a mortgage I need a minimum rating of E39.

My house is a 1900s solid brick, mid-terraced property, with a rear extension, which was build around the 1950’s. The extension has cavity walls that are filled with insulation. The main dwelling has loft insulation in between joists of 300mm Rockwool, whereas the rear extension has a flat roof at that is not insulated.

The house has a boiler that is about 30 years old.

In the new EPC rating, produced yesterday, my house got a lower EPC rating. There have been no changes at all in my house since the first time it was assessed in 2014. Why did it rate lower this time?”

ANSWER

Short answer: nothing “mystical” happened to your house — the assessment framework and/or assumptions almost certainly changed.

Longer answer (this catches people out all the time in EPC work ?):

1) The methodology has changed since 2014

Your 2014 EPC was calculated using an older version of SAP (Standard Assessment Procedure) / RdSAP.

Since then, updates (notably RdSAP 9.92 → 10 and beyond) tightened assumptions. In general, newer versions are less generous unless there’s solid evidence.

Typical impacts:

  • Older boilers penalised more harshly

  • Default U-values for walls/roofs made less optimistic

  • Thermal bridging and infiltration treated more realistically

Result: the same house can score lower today.

2) “Evidence vs Assumption” is a big deal

If the assessor in 2014 assumed improvements (or was more relaxed), you may have benefited.

Now, assessors must follow stricter evidence rules under BRE Group guidance:

  • No proof of cavity wall insulation? → treated as uninsulated

  • No proof of flat roof insulation? → assumed none

  • No boiler documentation? → default (often worse efficiency)

That flat roof on your extension is a red flag:

If it’s recorded as uninsulated, it can drag the score down quite a bit.

3) Your boiler is a major factor

A ~30-year-old boiler is brutal for EPC scoring.

Even if unchanged:

  • Older EPCs sometimes gave more forgiving default efficiencies

  • Newer ones apply stricter seasonal efficiency assumptions

This alone can shift a few SAP points.

4) Small input differences = real score changes

Even when “nothing changed,” the inputs might have:

  • Floor area measured differently

  • Extension treated differently (thermal separation vs same dwelling)

  • Window types reclassified (e.g. unknown → double glazing assumed worse spec)

  • Heating controls recorded differently

EPCs are model-based, not measured — so tiny data differences matter.

5) Human factor (it happens)

Two assessors rarely input a property identically.

Especially with:

  • Older properties (like your 1900s solid brick)

  • Mixed construction (solid + cavity + extension)

  • Limited documentation

What I’d do in your position (practical, not theoretical)

Since you’re right on the mortgage threshold (E39 vs E43), this is worth pushing:

✔ Ask for the input data sheet

Check:

  • Flat roof → marked uninsulated?

  • Cavity wall insulation → marked “assumed” or “unknown”?

  • Boiler model → correctly identified?

✔ Provide evidence if you have it

Even photos or old paperwork can help:

  • Cavity wall insulation certificate

  • Loft insulation proof (you said 300mm — that’s good)

  • Boiler make/model

✔ Consider a targeted reassessment

Sometimes a second EPC (with better evidence) can recover points.

Reality check (important)

Even if everything is “correct,” your setup has two structural drags:

  • ❌ Uninsulated flat roof

  • ❌ Very old boiler

Those two together can easily knock you below E39.